Stuffed Safari Reviews

Stuffed Safari has an overall rating of 3.8 based on 233 reviews. Customer feedback on Stuffed Safari is mixed: Stuffed Safari reviewers highlight positive aspects like high-quality stuffed animals, excellent customer service, fast shipping and great selection, which strongly appeal to parents, gift shoppers, and stuffed animal enthusiasts. However, Stuffed Safari is often criticized for its higher price point, limited international shipping options and occasional stock issues.

3.8/5.0

233 reviews

5 Stars

9

4 Stars

8

3 Stars

6

2 Stars

4

1 Star

0

All Stuffed Safari Reviews (233)
Kelly.bolen
May 29, 2026
"Really cute little sloth plush"
I ordered the stuffed sloth for my niece, and it came looking pretty much exactly like the pictures. The size matched the description too, which is always the thing I get nervous about when ordering online. It’s soft, doesn’t have any weird smell, and the stitching seems solid. it’s even cuter in person, kind of like... well, she grabbed it right away and wouldn’t put it down. Shipping was quick enough and checkout was simple, so I’m happy with it.
Lewis.strange
May 27, 2026
"Cute site, but I expected more options"
To be fair, the site is really cute and easy enough to browse. I just thought there would be a bigger selection. I was hoping to find some more unusual animals and different sizes, but there weren’t as many choices as I expected, so I ended up giving up quickly
Ann_mariscal87
May 09, 2026
"Finally found the character my kid wanted"
My kid had been asking for this specific character, and after checking a few other shops that were sold out, I was glad to find it here. We’ve had trouble in the past ordering plush toys that showed up looking a little off, but this one looked just right. Shipping was fine too, so overall it was a good experience.
MikeLaymon
April 29, 2026
"I was hoping the toy would look like..."
I was hoping the toy would look like the photos, and it really did. The colors were accurate, and it might even be a little fluffier in person, which was a nice surprise. Overall, it met my expectations and I’m happy with it.
william_Wallace83
April 27, 2026
"I got this stuffed fox for my..."
I got this stuffed fox for my kid and it looks a lot like the pictures. The face and fur coloring is realistic, not overly cartoon-y or anything. One of the seams are a little uneven, but it’s not a big deal. My kid loves it, so I’m happy with it overall.
JuanitaDewald_87
April 23, 2026
"Don’t fully trust it"
My order did arrive. But the whole thing felt a bit off. Updates were slow. I had to ask what was going on. The stuffed animal was fine, just not as cute as the photos. Nothing awful. I just didn’t feel totally confident. I’d probably think twice next time...
verda-Card
April 20, 2026
"Size was actually just like they said"
I ordered a plush for my niece i kept thinking it was going to show up smaller than the pictures. I’ve had that happen before and it’s so annoying, like really annoying, when the photos make something look bigger than it is.

But this one was pretty much exactly the size they listed on the site. No weird surprise, no tiny plush situation, no annoying “why did I pay for this” moment. I was glad about that, seriously glad. Easy 5 stars from me.
Richard_abner87
April 13, 2026
"Good selection, with a few gaps"
I was trying to find a specific stuffed fox, and they actually had it when a few other sites didn’t, so that was a nice surprise.

A couple of sizes and colors were out of stock, so I had to go with my second choice on one item. It wasn’t the end of the world, but obviously it’s a little annoying when you can’t get exactly what you wanted.
Overall, the inventory was good and the site was easy enough to use. I’d shop here again, assuming they keep the popular stuff in stock.
hello_curtis001
April 03, 2026
"Finally, a stuffed animal that’s actually worth it"
I’ve bought way too many stuffed animals that look cute online and then show up feeling cheap or start falling apart almost immediately. This one was actually a relief. It’s super soft, feels well made, and doesn’t have that flimsy, poorly stitched feel. For once, I don’t feel like I wasted my money
JamesPack
March 19, 2026
"I ordered a plush and ended up..."
I ordered a plush and ended up having to reach out to customer service for a shipping update. They did respond, which was nice, but only after a couple of days and after I sent a follow-up because apparently patience is part of the process. Once they finally got back to me, they were polite and answered my question, so I’ll give them that. Overall, it wasn’t a terrible experience, just not exactly ideal if you’re hoping for quick help...
hello_william012
March 18, 2026
"Got the wrong stuffed animal"
I ordered a brown stuffed dog, but somehow a grey cat showed up instead. I mean, how does that even happen? Shipping was fine and didn’t take too long, but getting the completely wrong item was frustrating. Would I order again? i’m not so sure.
carl.Arnold
March 15, 2026
"I had to send back a plush because..."
I had to send back a plush because I accidentally ordered the wrong one. Since the refund wasn’t instant, I had to wait a few days and wasn’t totally sure what was happening at first. Customer service did get back to me though, and the refund went through fine after that. It wasn’t perfect, but it also wasn’t a major hassle. I’d order again, but clearer refund updates would make the process easier
Louise_leonard91
March 08, 2026
"I found a coupon for Stuffed Safari and..."
I found a coupon for Stuffed Safari and it did take a little bit off, but not enough to get too excited about. After shipping, the prices still felt kind of high. It’s nice when they have a promo running, but I wish the deals were better. Also, I ended up waiting in the checkout queue longer than I expected, which made the whole thing a little more frustrating.
BENITEZ
March 03, 2026
"Super Soft and Totally Kid-Approved"
This plush is genuinely very soft and has a nice, cozy feel to it. My kid absolutely loves it and has been carrying it around everywhere. Overall, it’s a great little purchase and definitely worth it if you’re looking for something cuddly.
bridget.Levitsky
February 22, 2026
"Finally, a site that didn’t make things difficult"
I was expecting to waste a bunch of time like I usually do with these sites, but I actually found what I needed super fast. For once, I didn’t feel like I had to struggle just to get something simple done
michael1996
February 05, 2026
"Payment options are "just okay""
My experience was fine overall, but the payment options felt a bit limited. It would be nice to have "more choices" available at checkout.
hello_kathleen383
February 05, 2026
"Good updates and a fair experience overall"
I had a good experience with my order. They sent regular updates about the order and shipping, which I appreciated because it felt fair to be kept in the loop. One email came a little later than I was expecting, but everything still arrived fine and they did a solid job communicating overall. I’d be comfortable ordering from Stuffed Safari again.
Marylou_mosier99
February 03, 2026
"Shipping felt reasonable to me"
I was mostly just happy the shipping cost didn’t annoy me. It was clearly shown at checkout, and there wasn’t some random extra fee popping up at the last second. For me, that made the whole order feel a lot easier
richard1985
February 03, 2026
"Good packaging, just a little squished"
I ordered a stuffed animal from stuffedsafari.com, and the packaging was solid. The box was sturdy and taped up well, so nothing was damaged when it showed up, which I appreciated because I’m always a little paranoid about packages getting tossed around.
The only reason I’m going with 4 stars is that the plush was a bit squished inside the box. To be fair, I probably noticed it more because I was being picky and opened it right away, but it did fluff back up after sitting out for a bit. Not a huge deal at all, I just think it could’ve used a tiny bit more room
JosephLucas
January 28, 2026
"I bought this planning to give it..."
I bought this planning to give it as a gift, but something feels off about the presentation. It didn’t really look ready to hand over as-is, so I ended up needing to wrap it myself first.

View More Reviews

Stuffed Safari Q&A

I found search8 as a discount code but when i put it in the order spot it did not change the price. is this the right code?

I have a promo code, but i forgot to put it with my order. is it too late. i ordered it today.

Does purring cat have a mechanism to cause it to purr realistically? does it actually make a purring sound?

I just placed an order yesterday afternoon to be shipped to canada on for my daughter's christmas gift? will it make it before christmas?

Hi there, i live in canada and i was wondering if there are duty charges on your items?

View More Q&As

Have a question about Stuffed Safari?
stuffedsafari

Stuffed Safari Reviews

Coupons & Promo Codes

Customer Reviews

Questions & Answers

Ask a Question

Welcome to WorthEPenny.com! We use cookies to better understand your preferences, optimize our website and services, enhance user experiences, personalize content and ads, and provide social media and other third-party features. If you want to learn more about cookies and why we use them, visit our Cookie Policy page.